The above question could relate to both sides ahead of the third test in Perth this week, but it is certainly more pertinent for the hosts as they try and get some semblance of pride back.
The glamour down under since England�s thrashing of the baggy greens has been almost vitriolic. Indeed some media outlets have even called for the great Shane Warne to come back and take over from Ponting, but that�s a step way too far.
Article continues below...
If I was an Australian selector (thankfully I�m not) I certainly wouldn�t panic as England used to back in the day when they re-selected Hick and Ramprakash time after time. A few tweaks here and there and maybe by the fifth test the Aussies might be able to give England a game.
With Simon Katich out for the series I don�t think they should automatically go back to young Philip Hughes. The England bowlers have him worked out well and truly and if Tremlett does indeed play then Hughes will get a barrage of the short stuff he hates.
In the spinner department it�s obvious Doherty was selected because Kevin Pietersen has a supposed weakness against left arm spin. The plan worked in a fashion as Doherty did indeed get KP out, but only after he had blasted a career best 227. If Warne isn�t tempted to stand in the field for two days aged 41 then the hosts should go back to Nathan Hauritz or even leg spinner Cameron White.
England also have a selection issue but luckily it�s not based on bad form but rather injury to Stuart Broad. I first saw Broad in a T20 game back in 2006 and even then I thought then he had something about him as a bowler. I think he is a very talented cricketer indeed and will be a loss to the side and the squad as a whole.
England now have a three way battle for Broad's place in the team between Tremlett, Bresnan and Ajmal Shahzad. If coach Flower and skipper Strauss want to go like for like then it�s a simple case of picking the all rounder Bresnan. However if Perth is the fast, bouncy wicket it normally is the Tremlett must get the nod.
The England top six is certainly good enough to get the runs so playing the extra bowler is not a gamble at all with Swann a more than cable lower order batsmen.
The Adelaide test will surely go down as one of the best England performances of all time and rightly so. Everything that could go well did go well and then some. The batting was world class, the fielding outstanding and the bowling on a flat pitch simply phenomenal.
Before the series started I predicted a 2-1 for England but now I think that was optimistic on behalf of the hosts. I now predict England will win two of the last three tests with a draw somewhere to end it 3-0 to England.
A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST �41.00 ON ASTON VILLA v TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
The Christmas Premier League programme starts on Sunday now and did you know that it is possible to win money on the Boxing Day evening clash between Aston Villa and Tottenham Hotspur, whatever the result?
The game kicks off at 5.30pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least �41.00, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least �41.00 better off, whatever the result of the match.