SUNDERLAND v NEWCASTLE: WILL THE FORM BOOK GO OUT OF THE WINDOW?
Betfair: 21 October 2012
Reproduced with permission from betting.betfair.com. (c) The Sporting Exchange Limited.
Sunderland have a terrible record against Newcastle. Black Cats fan Jonathan Wilson wonders if they can reverse that trend today...
The cliché has it that the form book goes out of the window for derbies but heading into Sunday's Wear-Tyne derby, neither Sunderland nor Newcastle are in any kind of form. Both have had weirdly enigmatic starts to the season and to an extent how fans feel about the first two months of the season will be conditioned by what happens on Sunday.
Sunderland's start to the season is particularly difficult to read. Taken in isolation, each of their results seems, at the worst, acceptable. An away draw at Arsenal was a fine start. A draw at Swansea, who had won their first two games, was fine. A point away at West Ham, who had won their previous five at home, was decent. Nobody would quibble too much about a home draw against Liverpool, even given their disappointing start to the season. A defeat at Manchester City was predictable and they won at home against Wigan.
Article continues below...
Had the home game against Reading not been postponed because of heavy rain and been won, Sunderland would probably feel they'd had a decent start to the season. As it is, it feels almost as though they haven't started yet and seven points from six games leaves them four points above the relegation zone and just feeling a little anxious.
After Newcastle comes an away game at Stoke: given how poor Sunderland's records are at home to Newcastle and at the Britannia, they could easily end the month just a point or two off the bottom three. I don't think they will be relegated but the 18.5 available on them to go down looks very generous; if November, when they face Aston Villa, Queen's Park Rangers and West Bromwich Albion at home, goes badly, that price will shorten dramatically.
And Sunderland's record at home to Newcastle is awful: they have won only one of their last 14 derbies on Wearside. That game they did win, in October 2008, left them so discombobulated that they lost six of their next seven games, leading to the departure of Roy Keane as manager.
There's little in their own form this season to make Sunderland fans optimistic. Six games have brought only five goals, all of them scored by Steven Fletcher. Nobody else has really looked like scoring with Stephane Sessegnon, in particularly, failing to offer the threat he did last season. They've had only 6.3 shots per game, the worst in the league. On all but one occasion when they have taken the lead, they've then surrendered it; even the win over Wigan stemmed from a red card to Jordi Gomez that was later rescinded.
But Newcastle haven't been much better, taking nine points form seven games and struggling to recapture the verve of last season. Their tally of 76 long balls is eight more than any other team in the Premier League and their attacking plan seems limited to getting the ball forward to Demba Ba or Papiss Cisse as quickly as possible.
That so far has yielded just eight goals in seven games, suggesting this will be low scoring. With that in mind 1.82 on under 2.5 goals in the game seems reasonable value particularly given six of the last eight derbies at the Stadium of Light have yielded two goals or fewer.
Sunderland will be without the suspended Lee Cattermole, which weakens their midfield. He may at times seem a liability but it's no coincidence that, without him, against Wigan and Manchester City there were times when Sunderland were overrun in midfield. The worry for Sunderland is that something similar happens on Sunday. Similarly, although Sunderland have conceded only eight goals so far, much of that has been down to the excellence of Simon Mignolet in goal. The partnership of Carlos Cuellar and John O'Shea has yet to gel at centre-back and it's easy to imagine the power and mobility of Ba causing them problems.
That's why I fear - I am a Sunderland fan, after all - another Newcastle win today. I'd be tempted to back them to win 1-0 10.0 and 2-0 17.5. I just hope I'm wrong.
Click here for a free £25 bet from Betfair.
|