JEFF WINTER'S WEEKEND REVIEW
MAJOR TALKING POINTS FROM SPURS v MANCHESTER UNITED AND LIVERPOOL v EVERTON

Jeff Winter: 18 January 2011

jeff winter

Saturday�s games passed by without major incident but on Sunday there were talking points at two of the four drawn Premier league games. Not surprisingly Liverpool and Manchester United were the two sides that were complaining the most.

King Kenny has not managed to win any of his first three games but he has not been slow at having a post match whinge regarding decisions that he has felt aggrieved about. His Liverpool side lost the lead then fought back to get Kenny�s first point in the derby against Everton. Dalglish was not happy about either of Everton�s goal.

He complained that the first came from a corner that should have been a goal kick. He has a point because as two players went for the ball it was toe poked by the attacker not the defender. This was only really evident with slow motion replays, so criticising the referee was a little harsh.

Article continues below...



Perhaps his anger should have been aimed at his defenders who allowed Distin an unopposed header at the back post. Kenny was also aggrieved at Everton�s second but for me Anichebe�s aerial challenge on Kelly was fair and was worthy of the free kick that the Liverpool boss wanted. I fear that we may hear more moaning from Kenny until he gets a side capable of playing the type of football that he is remembered for playing and that his sides played previously.

The Spurs v Manchester United game failed to live up to the pre match hype, though United will be happier with the point than Spurs or the other sides fighting for the title. Also for the first time in a while Spurs supporters had no real grievances with match affecting refereeing decisions.

It was left to Mike Phelan to complain about Rafael's sending off as Fergie continues to refuse to speak to the BBC. My take on the Brazilian's eventful afternoon regrettably does not show him in great light.

His challenge that earned him a yellow card was reckless. I did feel though that Mike Dean was correct in not showing him a red card. It was borderline but Rafael was going for the ball and whilst his foot was off the ground it was not stud first, so a yellow card was correct.

It was very disappointing to see him waving the imaginary card requesting an opponent to be cautioned. Similarly in the Merseyside derby Liverpool players seemed to be pressuring Phil Dowd to send off Tim Howard.

I wish refs would automatically yellow card any player who acts this way. Tough if it�s their second yellow. It is cowardly and does nothing for the image of the game. Maybe it is something that a sin bin could be used for. The FA should at least issue heavy fines for this act.

I have to say that I felt sympathy for the United full back when he picked up his second yellow. Quite often we see players claiming innocence when they have clearly committed a foul. On this occasion I thought it was a coming together and whilst within the laws of the game it was a foul it was not a yellow card and most certainly not a second yellow card.

Having been sent off though, his in the face verbal aggression towards the ref was bang out of order. That needs to be knocked out of his game. He certainly has a lot of ability but it comes with attitude, emulating his long time predecessor in the right full back position at United.

Once again Wayne Rooney did not come out of the incident with too much credit. His foul mouthed opinions to the ref earned him a yellow card which could easily have been a red.

It is always the case that the biggest teams, who are more used to winning, are the worst when it comes to dissent. Referees know that upsetting those clubs does them no favours as the authorities tend to be unlikely to support them and mete out punishments, then therefore turn a deaf ear to the worst abuse and it continues to go on setting a very bad example to youngsters.

Have a good week.


A GUARANTEED PROFIT OF AT LEAST £54.00 ON MARSEILLE v MANCHESTER UNITED

There's another round of Champions League matches this midweek and did you know that it is possible to win money on Wednesday evening's clash between Marseille and Manchester United, whatever the result?

The game kicks off at 7.45pm UK Time and we can guarantee you a profit of at least £54.00, whatever the result of the match. All you have to do is follow the simple instructions below and then sit back and enjoy the game. At full-time, you will be at least £54.00 better off, whatever the result of the match.

Click here for full instructions on how to make £54.00 on Marseille v Manchester United, whatever the result...




Back To Jeff Winter Index

Click here to order a copy of Jeff's autobiography

Click here to read all of Jeff's regular articles and to write to Jeff...


Send this to a friend


COMMENTS ON THIS ARTICLE

Kopite, January 18, 2011 at 2:48 pm
"I fear that we may hear more moaning from Kenny"

Who the **** are you to be supposing what the King may or may not do?!


goonerista, January 18, 2011 at 2:56 pm
You're right Jeff. Big team players, especially english ones like JT, Stevie G and Rooney gets away with murder time after time. CFC is specialists with JT, Cashley and Lamps on crowding refs. Its pathetic.
And to you Kopite, if I were supporting a midtable team I would step down from my high horses right now....




Drew, January 18, 2011 at 2:59 pm
What was your take on the reckless, dangerous lunge made on Giggs by Crouch, that surprisingly has gone unmentioned?


Reno, January 18, 2011 at 3:06 pm
No mention of the series of professiomal fouls from Vidic, notably pulling Van der Vaart off his feet in the box. Penalty? Red card?
That, if spotted, would have made a far bigger difference to the game than Raphaels inevitable second yellow.
Even though Man U supporters feel hard done by. I still feel that refs give them far too much leeway.


Jima, January 18, 2011 at 3:19 pm
It was worthy of a second - as you pointed out it's tough if it's a second yellow regards to trying to get another player booked, and the same applies with this, soft, but still a yellow. BAE was on the break with several Spurs players around, the foul deliberate or not, meant Spurs missed out on a forray forward, it happens all the time where because the opposition are on the break a yellow follows a foul, watch the whole incident again.


George Phillips, January 18, 2011 at 3:28 pm
Cheers Jeff. Must agree with you about Rafael. Most pundits agree too. Mike Deane scares me when I see him up for United.


Tiral, January 18, 2011 at 4:19 pm
Jeff, I'm surprised, once in a while you do see a man utd point of view. Cheers.

However, theres a certain amount of double standards from you. You said tough luck if its their second yellow card, they should be sent off for waving an imaginary card. Further down,you say rafael shouldn't have a yellow for his second challenge, and then made a distinction that it was his second yellow, so that it was less worthy of a second yellow than if it was his first.

I respected you as a referee. Brilliant in an arsenal utd game I saw. It's just a shame your blogging isn't good enough for you to be hired by the Sun.


 
Name:
Email:
Your Comment:




© All written site content is copyright SportingPreview.com 2010-2011, unless otherwise stated, and is not to be used without prior permission.
   Search Site | Terms and Privacy | Set as Homepage | Contact
Web Statsrestore file